Image: The state court premises
in the historic city surrounded by
the new construction
1.2 Methodology
This report was compiled by the Centre of Public
Administration at the University of Ulster with
contributions from the Uzbek Forum for Human Rights
and Land Home Justice, a network of independent
experts and civil rights activists in Uzbekistan. The
report findings reflect the cumulative effort of the
parties who have been collating evidence on violations
of housing rights in urban centres, governance and
corporate failings, and violations involving land
confiscations in rural areas. The monitoring and
documentation of land confiscations was undertaken
by the Uzbek Forum for Human Rights. The research on
home demolitions involving forced evictions, property
violations and, in part, destruction of cultural heritage
was carried out by members of the Land Home Justice
Network throughout the period 2017–2024.
This collaboration is precipitated by a number of
significant events. The first was the initiation of a
mega-property development in the heart of Tashkent
known as Tashkent City, which had prompted mass
evictions, public protest and serious allegations of
corruption. The second was the national government’s
launch of a cluster system to reform cotton production
in Uzbekistan, which precipitated large-scale land
acquisitions from farmers and the redistribution of
this land to clusters controlled by agro-industrial
conglomerates. These events prompted independent
research by the partners involved in this report,
including interviews with victims, gathering case
files and attending court hearings.
These initial studies pointed to significant breaches
of property rights, due process and the human rights
of homeowners, farmers and businesses. In order to
consolidate these findings, conduct further inquiry and
publish the results, the researchers involved in these
different streams of research initiated a collaborative
study in 2021, which aimed to monitor state-organised
land acquisitions and major real estate developments.
From 2021–24, the collaboration team conducted
periodic meetings in order to design the research
methodology, implement fieldwork, review the results
and write up the findings.
State-facilitated acquisition of homes involving human
rights violations in urban centres focusing on Tashkent
and Samarkand were documented by members of the
Land Home Justice Network. The network members
have been documenting forced evictions in Uzbekistan
since 2017. During the period 2021–2024, the network
members took part in a collaboration to facilitate
systematic monitoring and the construction of a case
study database on housing rights violations. The network
members have monitored 11 urban development
projects involving forced evictions, gathering the
testimonies of 40 victims. Furthermore, a documentary
film has been produced to capture the human costs
of the problem. Case files along with interviews, court
documents, open-source data and other supporting
documents were uploaded to Uwazi, a human rights
database platform, for further verification and
qualitative analysis.
A False Sense of Legality 7