106. 107. 108. 109. 110. 111. 112. 113. 114. 115. 116. 117. 118. 119. 120. 121. 122. 123. On the Protest of the Prosecutor of the Samarkand Region for No. 10/2850 dated 7 October 2017, City of Samarkand Mayor, decree no. 1755-K, 14 October 2017. 124. Judgement, Samarkand City Civil Court, Presiding Judge Norov, B.U., 21 December 2017. ‘Regulation on the Procedure for Compensation of Losses to Citizens and Legal Entities in Connection with Seizure of Land Plots for State and Public Needs’, contained in On Approval of the Regulations on the Procedure for Compensation of Losses to Citizens and Legal Entities in Connection with Seizure of Land Plots for State and Public Needs, Cabinet of Ministers resolution no. 97, 29 May 2006. Available online: https://lex.uz/docs/1004599 125. 126. Letter from Samarkand City Prosecutor B.S. Oblakulov to the Judicial Collegium Samarkand Regional Court for Civil Affairs, 21 April 2018. Court of Appeal, Samarkand Regional Court for Civil Cases, case no. 4-507-18, Presiding Judges Turdaliev, Sh., Zhabborov, A. and Khudaiberganov, B., 7 June 2018. On Amendments to the Decision of the Khokim of the City of Samarkand for No. 1510-K dated August 15, 2017, City of Samarkand Mayor, decree no.1217-K, 6 July 2018. Silk Voyage, company extract, Unified Register of Legal Entities, Republic of Uzbekistan, accessed on 7 March 2022. Judgement, Samarkand City Civil Court, case no. 1-14834-18, Presiding Judge, Ramazonov, Sh., 26 December 2018. Judgement, Court of Appeal, Samarkand Regional Court for Civil Cases, case no. 4-126-19, Presiding Judges Turdaliev, Sh., Esanova, G. and Khudayberganov, B. 127. 128. 129. 130. 131. Judgement, Samarkand City Civil Court, case no. 1-18523-19, Presiding Judge, Ismoilova, M., 4 June 2019. Judgement, Samarkand City Administrative Court, Presiding Judge Karimov Zh.T., 29 August 2019. On Administrative Proceedings (2018), Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan. Available online: https://lex.uz/docs/3527365 Judgement, Court of Appeal, Samarkand Regional Court for Civil Cases, case no. 3-351-19, Presiding Judges, Turdaliev, Sh., Khudayberganov, B. and Ramazanov, Sh., 12 September 2019. 132. 133. 134. Judgement, Supreme Court of Uzbekistan, Case No.12-3140-19, Presiding Judges, Parpiyeva, G., Kasymov, A. and Rabbiev, M., 12 September 2019. ‘The court sentenced Dilorom Rozikova’, Gazeta, 13 June 2020. Available online: https://www.gazeta.uz/ru/2020/06/13/roziqova 135. Email communication from UN Human Rights Committee, 1 June 2021. On Land Allocation to the Training Project Limited Liability Company, Tashkent City Mayor, decree no. 488, 27 March 2018. ‘Justice in the service of the hokimiyat’, Uzmetronom, 19 September 2019, available online: https://uzmetronom.agency/2019/09/19/ pravosudie_na_sluzhbe_khokimijata.html; ‘There is an article, there is no precedent’, Uzmetronom, 12 December 2019, available online: https://uzmetronom.agency/2019/12/12/statja_est_precedenta_net. html; ‘Time’s up: Take your things out’, Anhor.uz, 10 September 2020, available online: https://anhor.uz/stroitelystvo-v-uzbekistane/23047-2 70 A False Sense of Legality 136. 137. 138. On Measures to Radically Simplify the System of Granting Land for Urban Development and Other Non-Agricultural Needs, as well as the Issuance of Permits for the Construction of Facilities, Cabinet of Ministers decree no. 54, 25 February 2013. Available online: https://lex.uz/docs/2138919 ‘Time’s up: Take your things out’, Anchor.uz, 10 September 2020, available online: https://anhor.uz/stroitelystvo-v-uzbekistane/23047-2; ‘Forced evictions in Uzbekistan: The story of Olga Abdullaeva’s struggle’, AsiaTerra, 4 December 2020, available online: https://m.asiaterra.info/corruption/prinuditelnye-vyseleniya-vuzbekistane-istoriya-borby-olgi-abdullaevoj Supervisory Complaint, case no. 3-1006-1901/4581, Applicants Tsirinsky, G.E., Ananova, R.V., Abdullaeva, O.A., Fadeicheva, M.V. and Kudryavtseva, N.G. Supervisory Complaint, case no. 3-1006-1901/4581, Applicants Tsirinsky, G.E., Ananova, R.V., Abdullaeva, O.A., Fadeicheva, M.V. and Kudryavtseva, N.G. Judgement, Administrative Court of the Chilanzar District of the City of Tashkent, case no. 3-1006-1901/4581, Presiding Judge Kuyumov, B., 23 August 2019. Residents also alleged in their statement of claim that the decision was not approved by the Kengash of people’s deputies Judgement, Administrative Court of the Chilanzar District of the City of Tashkent, case no. 3-1006-1901/4581, Presiding Judge Kuyumov, B., 23 August 2019; Judgement, Cessation Instance of the Tashkent City Administrative Court, case no.5-2405/19 B, Judges Mirzaeva, I.T., Dzhuraeva, D.B. and Khasanova Kh.M., 25 November 2019. ‘Regulation on the Procedure for Compensation of Losses to Citizens and Legal Entities in Connection with Seizure of Land Plots for State and Public Needs’, contained in On Approval of the Regulations on the Procedure for Compensation of Losses to Citizens and Legal Entities in Connection with Seizure of Land Plots for State and Public Needs, Cabinet of Ministers resolution no. 97, 29 May 2006. Available online: https://lex.uz/docs/1004599 Ibid., article 14. Judgement, Supreme Court of the Republic of Uzbekistan, Judge Nazarov, M., no date. The land plot and the house are located at 15a S. Azimov Street, Yashnabad District, Tashkent. It belongs to Olga on the basis of the following documents: certificate of ownership TS №0056207 dated 24 October 2014; certificate of the right to use the land plot TS №0011906 dated 24 October 2014; and cadastral documents dated 24 October 2014. Judgement, Mirobad Interdistrict Court for Civil Cases, case no. 2-1002-1904/26872, Presiding Judge Zakriova, M.I., 11 October 2019. Judgement, Tashkent City Court for Civil Cases, case no. 3-17/20, Judges Salahutdinov, D.N, Mirzaalimova, G.M. and Khakimova, N.Zh., 13 March 2020. Letter from the Human Rights Ombudsman Muhammadiev, U., to the Chairman of the Republic of Uzbekistan Supreme Court, Kamilov, K.F., 16 November 2020. Letter from U. Nazarov, Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Uzbekistan, to O. Abdullaeva, 17 June 2021.